The Struggles of Survival Show Debutants: A Call for Rethinking the Industry's Approach
The Struggles of Survival Show Debutants: A Call for Rethinking the Industry's Approach
A statement from an industry insider whose dreams of debuting through a survival show have been dashed, as over a year has passed without any activity. Concerns are growing as participants who once achieved their dreams through these shows find themselves inactive post-debut.
The Struggles of Survival Show Debutants: A Call for Rethinking the Industry's Approach
The Struggles of Survival Show Debutants: A Call for Rethinking the Industry's Approach
Last year, Mnet's 'Queendom Puzzle' and MBC's 'Fantasy Boys' debuted groups EL7Z UP and Fantasy Boys, respectively, but their activities remain in limbo. When asked about their plans, the response is often, "Nothing has been decided yet." Given the lack of buzz during the broadcasts, there is skepticism about the success of any future releases. This has led to growing dissatisfaction among fans and industry insiders.

Participants in these survival shows poured their hearts into what they saw as their one chance, dedicating themselves to the goal of debuting. They shed tears of joy upon achieving this dream, but now face disappointment due to the lack of post-debut activities.
The Struggles of Survival Show Debutants: A Call for Rethinking the Industry's Approach
The Struggles of Survival Show Debutants: A Call for Rethinking the Industry's Approach
Despite the poor ratings of 'Queendom Puzzle', Mnet launched 'Build Up: Vocal Boy Group Survival' earlier this year. 'Build Up' showcased aspiring vocal groups, including both newcomers and struggling artists seeking a second chance. The 4-member group B.D.U, formed through fierce competition, is focusing on overseas tours but struggles with domestic recognition and fanbase growth. B.D.U member Seunghoon, also the main vocalist of CIX, faces growing discontent among CIX fans due to his delayed return to group activities.

On October 18, JTBC's 'Project 7' premiered with a low 0.6% rating, while Mnet's 'Road to Kingdom: ACE OF ACE' also struggles with 0% ratings, failing to capture public interest. Despite participants' efforts to deliver top-notch performances and agencies' significant investments, the outcomes fall short of expectations. The minimal gains from these programs have led to criticism of wasted passion.
The Struggles of Survival Show Debutants: A Call for Rethinking the Industry's Approach
The Struggles of Survival Show Debutants: A Call for Rethinking the Industry's Approach
Apart from Mnet's 'Produce 101' series, few survival shows have left a lasting impression on the public. Repetitive formats and underwhelming results have led to waning interest. Nonetheless, some industry insiders continue to plan new survival shows, hoping for a miracle, while participants invest their talents with fervor. Amidst low ratings for many survival shows, SBS's 'Universe League' is set to air soon.

The dreams of participants hoping for a glamorous debut through survival shows are repeatedly dashed. Even when debut opportunities arise, actual activities are scarce, leading to growing dissatisfaction among fans and the industry. There is a rising call for a fundamental reevaluation of the essence and purpose of survival shows.

이소정 텐아시아 기자 forusojung@tenasia.co.kr